2018年8月13日 星期一

每個國際學生都需要學的邏輯閱讀能力



半個月前,我在天母開了一間課後學校,所有的課程都是針對國際學生而設計。

我對國際學生的定義 :
1. TAS / TES 或其他就讀國際部/雙語部的學生
2. 確定國/高中畢業會出國讀書的學生

會開這間課後學校最大的原因是我兩個兒子越來越大了,他們最想要去求學的地方是美國。剛好我熟悉美國升學系統的學術考試,從高的GRE/GMAT到中的SAT/ACT到低的SSAT/ISEE,都可以提供資源幫助他們準備。

我差不多花了八個多月的時間,設計一套銜接課程,目標是讓我兩個孩子的批判性思維與學術能力能不亞於在西方國家長大的孩子,並同時也為升學所需的學術能力考試做準備。

這套系統的第一階課程就是邏輯閱讀(The Logical Reading Approach)。

在西方國家的教育系統中,我們非常重視邏輯與批判性思維,並長期培養孩子們有這兩種能力。

我想要透過邏輯閱讀這個班來一步一步培養國際學生的批判性閱讀能力,因為在台灣的國際學生未來會去西方國家讀大學,這是他們必須要學起來的能力,而我也編選了一套閱讀教材來培養這種西方邏輯閱讀的思維。

一般來說,大部分國際學校的孩子並不是從幼稚園或國小一年級就一直在這個體制學習,而是從中後段期間才轉進去的,像是中學時才開始進入國際學校。因此大部分在台灣的國際學生在邏輯與批判性這一塊跟從小在西方國家教育長大的孩子相較是偏弱許多,但是偏偏他們未來在大學申請的路上又將齊聚一起競爭想要錄取的學校。

台灣的國際學生常採用一種passive reading的方式,也就是比較被動式的閱讀法。所以我要改變孩子們這種閱讀習慣,要他們閱讀的時候不要發呆,而是要很主動的一直問自己 : 這篇文章的用意是什麼? 這個作者的宗旨是什麼? 他要表達什麼? 他的依據是什麼?

在西方國家的大學課程或升學所需的學術考試,邏輯推理與批判性思維能力是無處不在。

以GRE/GMAT來說,學生很容易掉入命題師所設計的陷阱裡,幾乎閱讀的每一題都會有陷阱,所以如果你沒有習慣批判性思維,就會太容易上鉤。因為他們會設計很多干擾選項,讓你覺得這個選項特別好,但其實是錯的。

國際學生需要長期培養可以應對歐美國家升學考試的批判性思維,讓他們知道在答題時,為什麼這道選擇題不是A,因為怎樣怎樣。或為什麼不是B,因為怎樣怎樣。邏輯閱讀並不是在教學生怎麼找答案~找正解,而是訓練學生找錯誤~找為什麼除了正解以外其他的每個選項都是錯的,你要找到文章裡的論據來作為充分解釋的理由,而不是用你的直覺~覺得是錯的~感覺不對勁來選擇。你要有具體的根據來說明解釋為什麼錯誤的選項是錯的。

邏輯閱讀課程分兩個round,有分A班和B班,上學期是A班/下學期是B班,是用不同的教材。
這個班也算是某種銜接課程,因為學到的能力對大學學術閱讀/IB/AP/SAT/PSAT等都有幫助。

我的設計是一堂課閱讀兩篇。在課程的一開始,學生因為還不熟悉這種閱讀方法,而不太可能上完完整的兩篇,所以學生會有回家作業去完成跟複習。而字彙的部分,最理想是在第四或第五堂課開始會挑出常出現的單字,其實就是我會指出來他們需要背的單字。基本上字彙終究是很重要的,所以我會教字彙/替換字/換句話說/文法轉換等閱讀功能,而這些功能也是特別需要透過閱讀中來學習。像是在寫閱讀題目的時候,題目選項的答案跟內文就是在用替換字或不同的文法在考學生,所以孩子需要特別留意~也要好好學起來。

這個邏輯閱讀班適合TAS G7以上和TES Y8以上,或其他國際學校的G7以上學生學習。
也需要通過我編排的邏輯閱讀考試,來評估孩子現階段的程度是否適合進班學習。

如果有通過,就表示孩子目前的閱讀能力有達到跟美/英/澳/加等英文為母語國家的孩子們的平均閱讀水準。如果沒有通過,會建議還是要多重視跟培養孩子的閱讀習慣,也可以透過我們的1 on 2的課程來加強,幫助孩子個別培養閱讀能力,並提升銜接到邏輯閱讀班的進班門檻。

邏輯閱讀能力需要一步一步培養,批判性思維也需要一層一層建構。
一起幫助孩子們進步!


2018年8月5日 星期日

TOEFL reflections 7/28

Reflections on my recent TOEFL test:

I haven’t taken the TOEFL for about 2 years, and as I’m opening a new TOEFL class, I decided to sign up for two tests. I took the first test last Saturday, and the biggest surprise was not any new question format or previously untested content - these things have not changed one iota.

The biggest surprise to me was that even though I’m an unbelievably experienced test taker (I regularly take the SAT, TOEFL, and IELTS, as well as other tests), I still got lost on the way to the test center! I foolishly assumed that I knew which test center I’d be going to as I knew the area quite well. What I hadn’t banked on was that the test center had moved since I was last there, and I went to the wrong place. When I got to the building that displayed the name of the test center on Google Maps, the test center was nowhere to be seen. I ended up running up and down the street trying to find it. Eventually, I enlisted my champion wife’s help and she cooly notified me that I’d gone to the wrong area. I jumped in a taxi at 8:50 (the test starts at 9:00), and the driver, pretending to know where to go, dropped me off at another wrong place! What’s more, the pin on Google Maps was incorrectly placed too, so I ran around several large blocks before my academic writing teacher, Ms L, who was also taking the test, called me (at 9:10) and asked me where I was. She then gave me the correct directions. I got there at 9:15, and luckily, they still hadn’t started! All I can say is, “Thank God it wasn’t the SAT or the IELTS!” Those tests always begin on time - even if you’re 30 seconds late, it’s over! 

Anyway, thanks to my unscheduled morning run, I was covered in sweat and found it relatively hard to focus during the reading section.

Still, I did notice quite a few things. Here’s a quick breakdown of the test and a few things I noticed:

Reading: 

1) Different people get different experimental sections (加試) (I got additional reading, and I noticed that the third passage was unusually difficult for the TOEFL. Ms L had additional listening tests, and she had not been tested on that passage, so my suspicion that the third passage was an experimental section was confirmed).

2) The reappearance of the referent question (The word “it” in the passage refers to which of the following?) - this question type had become so rare that it had been removed from many TOEFL textbooks. Being able to discern what pronouns refer to is a very important skill for readers, so I was glad to see it in the test.

3) It is extremely important to reread the passage for the summary question. This is the final question at the end of most passages. I had to resist the urge to only choose my answers from memory alone - lucky I did resist the urge, because I discovered a previously appealing answer choice only appeared in a single sentence, which makes it a mere detail. Single-sentence details are rarely correct - usually, you’re looking for the answers with the greatest coverage (篇幅) (a paragraph beats a sentence), as well as looking for misrepresentations of the passage’s meaning. In this question type, eliminating the wrong answers is more important than selecting the right answers.

4) As usual, unlike the SAT, the vocabulary questions tested only the first definition of words. Also, there is often little context to discern the correct meaning of a word, so it’s imperative to improve your general and academic vocabulary.


Listening

1) It’s important to pay attention to steps in a method or in task completion. On Saturday, one question was asked about the first step in a three-step process. Two of the incorrect answers were the other two steps.

2) It’s critical to understand what is shown on the “blackboard” - it’s often tested. Don’t waste time trying to spell the word correctly - just write down the initials or the first few letters of each word.

3) The cool thing about the TOEFL is that the speakers try to direct you to the answers by saying things like: “What’s interesting is…”; “and this is crucial…,” as well as using strong transitions. Remember: If a speaker says something is important, they are talking to YOU directly - that point is usually tested.


Speaking:

1) Q1&2: I was once again happily surprised to be given familiar questions. These were old questions that I’ve taught many times. Again, nothing has changed in the speaking section: ETS keeps reusing the same old questions.

2) Remember to be natural in Q1&2. Keep away from templates!

3) Q3&4: Be sure to get enough (but not too many) details from the reading passage. 

4) Pay particular attention to ideas that are discussed both in the reading and listening sections.

5) Spend most of your answer time summarizing the listening section.

6) Q5: Similar to the last time I took the test, the speakers discussed the background and problem for most of the time. If you’re not careful, you’ll make the mistake of summarizing too much. Remember to answer the question by focusing on your choice and your reasons for making that choice.

7) Q6: Time management is important for all questions, but especially in Q6. It is better to stop talking about the first main point and sufficiently explain the second point than it is to spend the whole time talking about the first point in detail. If you only mention the first point, you’ll only get 50% for that question.


Writing

1) In the integrated writing test, once again, I saw a history passage about the sinking of a ship. ETS loves topics such as this!

2) I wrote 300+ words in 10 minutes. Then I spent 5 minutes paraphrasing so as not to repeat any key words. 

3) Templates are very useful for the Integrated section. If you design or learn a good template, you will save minutes by not having to think about paraphrasing.

4) Independent: I wrote my typical 5-paragraph TOEFL essay: Introduction, Concession, Rebuttal, Advantages, and Conclusion. 

5) As it was appropriate, I even used a rare personal example. Remember, examples are NOT necessary in academic writing. Only use them if it strengthens your main idea. Never use them just because a teacher has told you they’re a good idea. Most examples cause students to get a WORSE score!

6) Finally, it is critical to practice writing under time pressure. Force yourself to write whole essays from start to finish within the time limit. Do it until it becomes second nature. You can always fix up your essays later, but make sure you get used to writing quickly. While quality is more important than quantity, there is a direct correlation between essay length and high scores.


Anyway, I hope this mini article has been of help to you in your TOEFL preparation. I have tons of things I would like to share, but I can’t fit everything into a single article.

Good luck with your prep!